The CFTC wants prediction markets to stop blocking people from trading based on their state. Sounds simple enough, right? But there's one big problem: some of those restrictions exist because courts and state regulators required them.
Now, exchanges are being told to remove certain geographic restrictions or explain why they can't. It's the latest development in the fight over who gets to regulate prediction markets, and the companies caught in the middle aren't exactly in an easy position.
The CFTC Wants the Same Rules Across the Country
On November 5, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission issued new guidance giving federally regulated exchanges 30 days to address geographic restrictions that violate its impartial-access requirements.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig believes these markets should operate nationally rather than under a patchwork of state restrictions. The agency argues that limiting access based on location can hurt liquidity, make prices less reliable, and create problems for traders trying to manage their positions.
Think about someone who opens a position at home and then travels to another state. Depending on the restrictions, that person could suddenly find themselves unable to manage the trade. That's exactly the kind of situation the CFTC wants to avoid. The guidance also applies to intermediaries, including brokers and other companies that provide customers access to these exchanges.
Exchanges Have 30 Days, but There's a Catch
The CFTC isn't telling every exchange to immediately reopen trading everywhere. Instead, companies have 30 days to remove restrictions that violate the agency's interpretation or explain why removing them isn't feasible.
That second option matters because some platforms didn't choose to block certain states. They did it because regulators demanded changes, courts issued orders, or continuing to operate carried legal risks.
Just look at what's happening around the country:
- Michigan: Kalshi faces a court injunction restricting sports contracts, while Robinhood and Coinbase have agreed to limitations.
- Utah: Kalshi is fighting civil and criminal cases, while other platforms have pulled back on certain contracts.
- Nevada: Kalshi continues battling state regulators over access restrictions and whether its controls are working.
- California: A federal court has restricted Kalshi's sports contracts on certain tribal lands, although the order doesn't apply statewide.
Those situations aren't going away simply because the CFTC wants exchanges to operate nationally.
Kalshi is Stuck in the Middle
Kalshi has spent much of the year fighting states over whether its federally regulated event contracts should also fall under state gambling laws. Utah has gone a step further, filing criminal charges against Kalshi co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara. The federal courts haven't exactly made things easier. The Third Circuit sided with Kalshi in its New Jersey dispute, but the Ninth Circuit went the other direction when considering preliminary protection in Nevada.
Neither ruling settles every legal question, which leaves exchanges trying to figure out whose requirements they need to satisfy. If you're Kalshi, that's a tough spot. The federal regulator overseeing your exchange wants broader access, while state authorities are still trying to keep certain contracts out of their jurisdictions.
The Trade Handle Prediction Markets Take
We can see why the CFTC wants to end the state-by-state restrictions. It's hard to run a national prediction market when someone can trade a contract in one state but might lose access to it simply by crossing a state line. Still, there's a big difference between telling exchanges what federal rules require and actually clearing away the legal obstacles they're facing. Kalshi and other operators can't just ignore court orders because the CFTC released new guidance.
Some will probably have to return to court, while others may use the agency's option to explain why removing their restrictions isn't possible right now. For traders, don't expect every blocked market to suddenly reopen. The guidance doesn't automatically override existing restrictions, and there's still plenty to sort out before anyone knows how much access will actually change. The CFTC has made its position pretty clear. Now comes the harder part: figuring out what happens when federal expectations and state enforcement don't line up.