TradeHandle TradeHandle

CFTC Puts Kalshi and Polymarket Under Investigation

Caleb Tallman
Caleb Tallman Editor in chief
11/16/2026
CFTC Puts Kalshi and Polymarket Under Investigation

Michael Selig has been a pretty reliable supporter of prediction markets since taking over the Commodity Futures Trading Commission last December. He's defended the industry against state regulators, supported new trading products, and regularly talked about the value these markets bring to the financial world. That support apparently has its limits, as the CFTC is now investigating both Kalshi and Polymarket.

The investigations have been underway for months, with Kalshi recently receiving a warning about possible charges. It's an interesting development, given how closely the agency has worked with the industry, especially as Democrats prepare to take control of Congress in January.

Kalshi and Polymarket Have Different Problems

Kalshi's investigation centers on how the company introduced dozens of new contracts. The CFTC has raised the possibility of enforcement charges, although Kalshi maintains the issue stems from a procedural mistake. Polymarket's situation is a little different. Regulators are conducting a broader investigation that includes the company's 2022 settlement, when it agreed to prevent U.S. customers from accessing its platform.

Here's what we know so far:

  • Kalshi: The CFTC is examining procedures surrounding new product launches.
  • Polymarket: Investigators are reviewing several issues, including compliance with its earlier settlement.
  • Potential penalties: Neither company has been found responsible for violations through these investigations.

Both companies have pushed back against the idea that something unusual is happening. Kalshi government relations executive John Bivona described disagreements with the CFTC as a normal part of regulation, while Polymarket says it regularly communicates with federal authorities.

Selig Still Wants the Industry to Grow

What's unusual is that the CFTC hasn't stopped supporting prediction markets while conducting these investigations. The agency continues backing platforms in court as states challenge their ability to offer sports contracts. Selig also recently approved single-stock perpetual futures, opening another business opportunity for companies such as Kalshi.

That decision immediately drew opposition from established financial firms, including Citadel Securities and Cboe Global Markets, whose representatives filed a lawsuit challenging the approvals. For now, Selig appears comfortable taking both positions. He wants prediction markets to expand, but his agency also wants companies to follow the regulations governing their products.

Congress Could Make Things More Complicated

The timing isn't particularly convenient for Kalshi or Polymarket. Democrats are preparing to take control of Congress in January and have already identified prediction markets as an industry they want to examine more closely. Political relationships have also attracted attention. Donald Trump Jr. previously served as an adviser to both companies, although Kalshi announced Thursday that he had left his position because of his involvement with Polymarket.

The CFTC insists those connections won't influence enforcement decisions. Spokesperson Zach Fulton said the agency will pursue misconduct across financial markets regardless of political affiliation or jurisdiction.

The Trade Handle Prediction Markets Take

There's a difference between supporting prediction markets and giving the companies operating them a free pass. Selig has made it clear he believes these platforms belong in the financial system, but that doesn't mean every decision Kalshi or Polymarket makes gets automatic approval. We also wouldn't read too much into the investigations until we know whether actual charges follow. Regulators examine financial companies regularly, and an investigation alone doesn't establish that anyone broke the rules.

Still, the timing matters. With Congress preparing for tougher oversight and established financial firms challenging new products, Kalshi and Polymarket have more than state regulators to worry about. If prediction markets want to be treated like established financial exchanges, they'll have to accept the regulatory responsibilities that come with it.